Quick answer. All six ledgers here are genuine double-entry. What separates them is how much GAAP work they automate. Zoho Books, Wave and GnuCash are the cheapest and leave depreciation and deferred revenue to manual journals. Kantivo (our product, $299 a year, roughly $25 a month) automates them: a fixed-asset register that posts depreciation, revenue recognition schedules, automatic accruals, an audit log, journal-entry approval, year-end close, and GAAP or IFRS per company, on your own computer.
The comparison
| Ledger | Entry price | Accrual reporting | Depreciation / deferred revenue | Audit and approval | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kantivo (ours) | $299 a year for 2 companies | Yes, cash or accrual per company; GAAP or IFRS | Built in, plus automatic accruals | Audit log, journal-entry approval, year-end close | Windows (or our hosted edition); no payroll built in |
| Zoho Books | Free under $50k; Standard $15 a month annually | Yes | By manual journal | Audit trail; period locking from Standard | Inventory needs a higher plan |
| Xero | $27 a month | Yes | Fixed-asset register; confirm your plan | Transaction history | Entry plan: 20 invoices, 5 bills a month |
| QuickBooks Online | $38 a month | Yes | On the Advanced plan | Audit log | GAAP-heavy tools priced at the top tier |
| Wave | Free; Pro $19 a month | Yes | By manual journal | Basic | Bank imports cost extra |
| GnuCash | Free | Yes | By hand | Basic | One user; technical feel |
The checklist that matters
A CPA signs off on GAAP, not a vendor. Software earns the label by making these routine:
- Accrual-basis statements, switchable per company.
- A fixed-asset register that calculates and posts depreciation.
- Deferred revenue recognised on a schedule for subscriptions, retainers and deposits.
- An audit trail and an approval step for adjusting entries.
- A year-end close that moves profit to retained earnings cleanly.
For a cash-basis sole trader, manual journals are fine. For anyone reporting to a lender, board or investor, built-in tools pay for themselves at the first month-end. Kantivo's: fixed assets, revenue recognition, audit log, year-end close.
Our suggestion
Simple and cost-first: Zoho Books' free plan or Wave. Accountant insists on QuickBooks: QuickBooks Online, Advanced if you need recognition. Large cloud team: Xero. GAAP tooling at a small-business price, with the books on your own machine: Kantivo, an annual subscription at a rate held for 12 years.
Sources (checked November 16, 2026): Zoho Books pricing; Xero US pricing; Wave Pro; QuickBooks Online; GnuCash. Vendors change prices often; if something here is out of date, tell us and we'll correct it.