Both keep your books on your own computer after QuickBooks Desktop. The difference is how you pay, and who makes sure your history arrived intact.
If you want the cheapest long-run cost, a licence you buy once, or an install on a Mac or Linux machine, Solid Accounting is the stronger pick. If you'd rather hand over your QuickBooks files and get back books that are proven to match, your reporting depends on Items and Classes, you want browser access, or your accountant works in the file with you, Kantivo is.
| Kantivo | Solid Accounting | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Yearly: Basic $299, Pro $540, held for 12 years | Buy once: Standard $349, Professional $499, Accountant $699; updates and cloud services $99–$179 a year if you want them (year one included) |
| Five-year cost, one company | Roughly $1,495 | $349, or roughly $745 keeping the yearly plan |
| Getting your QuickBooks years in | IIF lists plus QuickBooks transaction reports, as many years as you have | Reads your .QBW or .QBB and builds a fresh company file |
| Checking it worked | Free done-for-you migration in the trial, with a written tie-out per account and year | A comparison report of each account against QuickBooks |
| Items, Classes, class tags on lines | All kept | Its page doesn't say |
| Operating systems | Windows, plus a hosted edition in any browser | Windows, Mac, Linux |
| Bank feeds | In every plan | Part of the optional yearly plan |
| Extra people | One seat included; more at $120 a year; accountants connect without a seat | Network sharing on Professional and up; extra users $100 each, once |
| Payroll | Not included | Imports payroll files; no payroll processing described |
Sources: solidaccounting.com/switch, solidaccounting.com; Kantivo pricing and import guide.
Pulling data straight out of a QuickBooks company file is convenient, and Solid deserves credit for it. Our importer works from the exports QuickBooks produces, which is a little more clicking. The bigger question is what happens after the data lands. Balances that are close but not quite right are where a migration costs you weeks.
That's why our trial includes the migration done by us: you send the files, we import every year into your own installation, and you get a written tie-out of each balance against QuickBooks. Anything that doesn't match gets fixed before you pay. Solid's page describes a comparison report; it doesn't describe help reconciling the differences.
One thing applies to both: move while QuickBooks can still open your file. Our route needs exports from QuickBooks, and Solid's page mentions approving its connection inside QuickBooks.
30 days free, or send us the files and we'll migrate and tie out every year for you.